Facebook appears to be doing an end run around the Google by pushing an update to the social network’s open app to Android users today… and the update isn’t coming from the Google Play Store. The Facebook app on your phone downloads the update automatically and then beeps or vibrates incessantly until you install it (or uninstall the app altogether).
So what does the new version of Facebook for Android do?
According to Facebook it lets you change your profile picture using the mobile app, allows you to hide stories and report spam, and start group messages more quickly.
But there’s one other thing the new app does: It allows itself to download future updates without alerting you.
If you look at the permissions required by the app, there’s a new one that says “download files without notification.”
This effectively lets the Facebook app for Android automatically download updates toyour device without going through the Google Play Store (although you’ll likely continue to be prompted to install them… and bugged until you do).
It’s not clear exactly why Facebook is taking this step. But once you’re prompted to download the new version of the mobile app the only alternatives appear to be to put up with annoying notifications or remove the Facebook app from your Android device.
Update: As The Verge notes, Facebook has updated its help pages confirming that yes, this is a real update, and suggesting that the goal is to “make sure everyone is using the best version of our app.”
No, I don’t know why Facebook felt that Google’s Play Store which prompts users for notifications whenever an update is available wasn’t good enough.
Update: If you haven’t been prompted to download the update, that’s apparently because Facebook is only rolling out the silent downloads to about 1 percent of its user base as a way to test out new features before bringing them to everyone.
TechCrunch has more details on the apparently involuntary beta program.
If I am not connecting to the internet via WIFI or Mobile Data, when Facebook changes are encountered and they push the changes,
a)If they push the changes to the app, will I still receive the notification, inspite of having no wifi or Mobile Data? or I will not get the notification. If I don’t get the notification, how do I know whether the change has occurred or no.
b)There are two options which are present :- Download without notification & Download with notification.
If I choose download without notification, how does the update happens silently? Does the app needs to be open or is there a daemon process which runs and on the notification, starts the app and downloads the files.
If I choose download with notification, Does the app needs to be open or is there a daemon process which runs and on the notification, starts the app and downloads the files.
c) Why is there an issue with the battery getting drained? Is there any daemon process running on the app all the time?
d) Are we planning to roll the same for IOS users?
Got root? Use permissions denied and you’re done.
i didn’t update last time n wont be this time either, i read that by updating the app i agreed to……. change passwords, change n view my contact in my phone, take pics, videos n voice recordings without me knowing, using my data usage without knowing (causing charges), can make calls from my device without my knowledge (at a possible charge). I don’t think so. i was reading some of the comments on the google play facebook update n 1 person said that the app was trying to get so much info that there spyware refused to let facebook open, now what is that saying. im going to be deleting the app n just go through my browser. i uderstand that they r trying to do resurch but this is invading into our personal lives, stuff on my phone is for me not fb 🙁
this app is still beta it means it still a subject for change and a decision they will make if this app will be accepted b the facebook user. You guys has this apps too? Did you try it?
I have an android and have not seen the update yet…FB is still really messing up via the Google App Store version. ;(
No thanks mate that’s fucked! .
I would rather wait untill an update is released via the play store. This undermines all credibility/trust I previously had. If I could squelch the notification I would but they don’t give you that option. Time to move on.
i have this nasty incling it’s a move towards a facebook phone… next step will be downloading apps through the facebook app.
They are doing it this way for a simple reason. I don’t know how many people I have come across who have not downloaded updates for ANY program for so long. Literally they have 15 updates waiting to be downloaded. I am sure giving you to update this way and forcing everyone to have the same version makes everyone have a smoother experience and less compatibility issues
Of course the reason we don’t update is because the current installed version of any random app works, while the odds of any random update breaking something is high. So once you get a working version you learn not to update unless one of the bugs in your version begin to bite. Then start to update that one app every couple of days until you eventually get another one you don’t hit any of the bugs with.
Come on! At least they should “warn” users about this. I thought my phone got some kind of virus. It’s simply a shame that they want “silent” updates when everybody must be alerted when installing something on our devices….
Am I the only one who thinks that facebook wants auto-updates so nobody thinks to read or look for the privacy changes that Facebook always try to slip past users?
Facebook is poor !
My facebook app kept trying to download without asking me and over the cellular network. I force-stoped it, checked that my Google Play setting was on “wi-fi only”, rebooted, and it again started to download over cellular.
I deleted the app.
As long you cant opt-out i’m do not have a problem with that.. data is not cheap in brazil. i have a huge problem with gpslocation everytime you open the app
I dont know about you, but I am starting to get really annoyed with facebook!
And this is why I use Friendcaster. Holo themed too
For those saying the new permission might have nothing to do with auto updating itself, please tell me why this update isn’t happening through the Google play store?
I too thought it was a rouge apps phishing scam at first. Then when I dismissed it and it kept popping up every few minutes I said “thanks for including a convenient uninstall button”
If you use fb app your phone junk
Like I need this shit using up my limited data plan. Removed.
Guess you missed the part in the screenshot above that says “Get app updates automatically over Wifi”. There is a time to panic over a corporate abuse and a time to stop and think a bit. This is more a case of invoking the 48hr rule and see what happens.
John, mine pushed down over 4G while I was driving. Their statement about only using wifi was a lie. Shocking. I don’t allow automatic or silent updates on my phone at all and really only want updates to come through the app store. Everything about this push was shady. The comment in their own help forum said it was done to keep everyone up to date, yet there is no update in Google Play. The other “silently download updates” is ridiculous. I’ll stick to m.facebook.com now, thanks. Some of us did stop and think about it. We still don’t like it.
Well then that sucks bigtime. Don’t do FB myself. Curious how FB plans to avoid being declared malware if they are that far outside the bounds of civilized behaviour.
Are you serious? This is the conclusion you jumped to? “Download” instantly means “install” And I suppose google reader (RIP) can install things everywhere too, if you have it set to sync. And text messages can install things. email. Where do you people hire your journalists?
Have you ever met a “tech journalist” who understood technology? They’re nothing but creative writing majors who happen to own iPhones.
This DOES NOT effectively let Facebook *automatically* update itself without going through the Google Play Store. Such behavior is simply not allowed on Android. That “download without notification” permission allows Facebook to use the DownloadManager service to retrieve files. The permission, “android.permission.DOWNLOAD_WITHOUT_NOTIFICATION” is provided by the DownloadProvider package, and has nothing to do with APK installation. Docs are here: https://developer.android.com/reference/android/app/DownloadManager.html
Any app that has obtained full internet access could do the same thing on its own, the Facebook devs simply are requesting this permission so they can have the download manager do it for them.
To install the downloaded APK, the Facebook app can only make a request of the OS that the new APK be installed. Doing so will result in a screen like the one on the left being shown EVERY TIME, requiring the user to confirm the installation. I don’t believe any permission is required to request an app install.
It’s also worth noting that even requesting an APK to be installed will fail unless the user has changed the default settings to allow sideloading of applications. This is typically under “Security” in the system settings, i.e.: “Unknwown Sources: Allow installation of an apps from unknown sources”.
You’re right… to a degree. It’ll download the update and bug the hell out of you until you install it, but it doesn’t do it automatically.
It’s still an end-run around the Play Store though.
But I’ll delete the word automatically or make that sentence a bit more clear.
Not so sure. Don’t a lot of AT&T locked phones still remove the option for sideloading altogether? If so, Facebook would have to take that reality into account and ensure that their app a) didn’t try it on any device where it would fail (and thus annoy the user) and b) that no update that eventually went around Play included a must have feature, since a large population would be locked out.
I’m leaning more to the desire to make use of download manager for some other, as yet unclear, purpose rather than building in an emergency end run around Google policy.
AT&T has allowed side loading since May 2011.
Good thing I don’t use Facebook.
I got that. Cancelled the download right away. I won’t tolerate that.
Hoow do you cancel it? It wont let me
I did not update my FB app once I heard FB wanted to make money with mobile users. No notice affecting me!
Sure, much rather they make no revenue and eventually shut down when they can’t turn a profit?
If they can’t do it without pissing folks off then call it evolution in action.
I’ll just have to be sure to get the latest version’s .apk for a backup before this update from somewhere… No doubt it’ll be on xda by now….
I belive this is the moment I delete the app. Downloading without me knowin is one thing, but beeping untill I install its update would be the last straw.
The “beeps or vibrates incessantly” part is not accurate.
No, he is correct. After clicking on the notification and changing to another app my phone continued to vibrate every few seconds. I had enough and uninstalled as well. Moved to Fast For Facebook.
too bad fast is ugly as hell
I deleted and am using Friendcaster on my phone, which allows you to see and interact with FB. It’s ridiculous to have to use second party software, isn’t Zuckerberg supposed to be smart?
I had this update and thought it was a phishing thing. I went to downloads in the app tray then deleted the download. Facebook works fine. It removed it from my phone and left the app alone.
Same here… but after I deleted it, I uninstalled Facebook, reinstalled it, and the download prompt popped up again.
I don’t use Facebook, but Android 4.1.2 on my Nexus S has been making changes to the OS on its own. A couple of weeks ago a green “Google Settings” app appeared in my apps list that wasn’t there before.
That isn’t the OS changing. Apps can have multiple launcher icons (like Google Maps has navigation). You simply received an update to a Google app which added an extra icon in your launcher.
It was still a silent update without any notification. you can’t villify Facebook without realising google are doing the same.
Difference is that I trust Google.
That might have been your first mistake. https://youtu.be/R7yfV6RzE30
The app was always there. It just didn’t have an icon in your app tray before.
No, it wasn’t a silent update. It was part of a Google Play update. Once it updated the new icon appeared – same old app existed though.
Just about every Android phone got the update IIRC.
It’s just a notification-less Google service update. Slightly annoyed by yet another icon, though I hardly go into my app drawer anyway.
Comments are closed.