The Participatory Culture Foundation has released Miro 4.0. While earlier versions of this open source media player were aimed at making it easier to find and download videos and watch internet video streams, Miro 4.0 aims to be a complete replacements for iTunes or Windows Media Player. It can handle audio and video podcasts, includes the ability to purchase media from Amazon and other digital media stores, and allows you to synchronize your media with an Android phone or tablet — if you can get it to work.

Unfortunately when I tried installing the app on my desktop computer running Windows 7 Home Premium, I couldn’t get past the setup screen because I had a series of pop-up errors telling me that the app couldn’t find a hard disk. Hitting cancel did no good at all.

Update: The developers have uploaded Miro 4.0.1 to the server, and it resolves all of the error messages I encountered, although you still have to mount your Android device’s SD card any time you want to sync media with your computer.

I’ve used Miro in the past and always found the app to be promising but not all that useful for my needs. Now that the developers are positioning the app as an all-purpose tool for managing and playing most media formats I was really looking forward to giving it another try.

The app did install properly on a Windows 7 laptop — but I saw a number of graphics glitches on the home screen. When I plugged in my Android smartphone, I got the same annoying error messages that had plagued the desktop PC installation until I realized that I needed to mount my phone’s SD card before using Miro’s new “connect” features. It’s not intuitive, and it’s not exactly the kind of synchronization I’ve come to expect from iTunes.

Once Miro 4.0 did recognize my Google Nexus One, it was able to scan the phone’s SD card to find music, podcasts, and videos — but it also found other sound files on the device including custom ringtones and “Facebook Pop” which I can only assume is a sound effect from the Facebook app.

Incidentally, unplugging my iPod touch and Android phone from my desktop didn’t make Miro run any better.

I really want to like Miro 4.0 because I love what the Participatory Culture Foundation is trying to do with this cross-platform media app for Mac, Windows and Linux. But it’s hard to like an app if you can’t get the thing to work.

Support Liliputing

Liliputing's primary sources of revenue are advertising and affiliate links (if you click the "Shop" button at the top of the page and buy something on Amazon, for example, we'll get a small commission).

But there are several ways you can support the site directly even if you're using an ad blocker* and hate online shopping.

Contribute to our Patreon campaign


Contribute via PayPal

* If you are using an ad blocker like uBlock Origin and seeing a pop-up message at the bottom of the screen, we have a guide that may help you disable it.

Subscribe to Liliputing via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 9,454 other subscribers

7 replies on “Miro 4 offers cross-platform, open source iTunes alternative… when it works”

  1. I use miro on my linux box and its really nice.. It is my music/movie player of choice now along with torrent downloader.. not a big fan that the .miro folder in the home folder is hidden by default because they went with the .miro folder name instead of just miro.. kind of annoying when you want to browse the folder but whatever.

  2. This seemed like a good idea, but Miro tries to install the zugo toolbar (without asking, BTW—I blocked that at the firewall); it changes your IE and Firefox homepage (without asking, BTW); and ultimately the Miro process would run, would complete the search the hard drive for media files, but the Miro application wouldn’t  open on Win7 Home Premium.

  3. Another update from the Miro team: the main bug described here, which only affects a tiny percentage of Windows users, has been fixed and will be released today.

  4.  I’m going to vote on windows UAC. I’ve experienced problems similar to that with other applications, and it could be something as simple as disabling UAC.

  5. Hi, I sent a note to your contact link. I’m part of the PCF team and would like to gather some more information about why you are experiencing those drive issues and the hang. It seems a bit unusual.


Comments are closed.