When location services are enabled on an Android smartphone you can use your device for turn-by-turn navigation, track your location history, get local news and weather specific to your location, and more.

But if you don’t like the idea of Google knowing where you are all the time, you can disable location services from the phone’s settings.

Unfortunately, it turns out that for most of 2017 disabling location services didn’t prevent your phone from sending some location data to Google’s servers. Quartz reports that some of that data was shared with Google even when users thought they had opted out. But Google is promising to change that behavior in the future.

Here’s what was going on: phones with location services disabled were still detecting the location of nearby cell towers and then sending that information to Google. This happened even on phones with no SIM card inserted. The only requirement was an internet connection so the phone could share the data with Google.

The company says it was using the data about cell tower locations to help “improve the speed and performance of message delivery” related to push notifications. But that data was never saved.

In fact, Google says that this data was always considered to be separate from location services, and opting out of one wasn’t meant to opt you out of the other… but in response to the Quartz report, Google is apparently changing course to stop collecting cell tower data.

One thing to keep in mind is that cell tower data is much less precise than other signals used by location services. Data from cell tower addresses probably wouldn’t tell Google if you’re at a specific restaurant, church, or club. But it would certainly be good enough to let an interested party know if you were going out of town.

The data that was sent to Google was said to be encrypted, but it’s possible that it could have been intercepted on a phone that had been compromised with spyware (although if you’ve got a phone with malware on it, location tracking may be just one of our problems).


Support Liliputing

Liliputing's primary sources of revenue are advertising and affiliate links (if you click the "Shop" button at the top of the page and buy something on Amazon, for example, we'll get a small commission).

But there are several ways you can support the site directly even if you're using an ad blocker* and hate online shopping.

Contribute to our Patreon campaign


Contribute via PayPal

* If you are using an ad blocker like uBlock Origin and seeing a pop-up message at the bottom of the screen, we have a guide that may help you disable it.

Subscribe to Liliputing via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 9,547 other subscribers

7 replies on “Google to stop collecting your phone’s location without permission (related: Google was collecting location without permission)”

  1. They’re fucking scumbags, there’s no way to permanently turn off location setting as it’ll randomly turn back on sometimes

  2. The data wasn’t being “collected”, but it was transmitted.
    Also, for the truly paranoid, the network provider that receives your transmission knows where you are.

    1. While correct, I have been paying my network provider for a service and obviously they have to know which tower to send my bits to. Also, Verizon has not been actively “policing” ideas and content that they dislike. Google has been.

      I was on the same femtocell as a Civil War re-enactment yesterday. Will I find my Google Apps (Gmail, sheets, etc) scrutinized for subversive (to Google) activity?

      Signed with Google Account # 4…

  3. Google is probably the most pervasive in tracking people across their Internet connected lives. Not surprised they were doing this without consent.

    Google probably found a different way to accurately track your physical location now instead so they can keep making money off you.

    1. No, that would be Verizon. From their zombie tracking cookie to their of net discrimination to their request to the FCC to bar state privacy and net neutrality laws, they are the ones who want to track and monetize you without your permission.

  4. I am totally shocked! Shocked I tell you! /s
    Google isn’t the only one. Your carrier knows where you are and can look back at old data to see where you were at any time in the past. The question is with how many entities are they sharing this data?

Comments are closed.