Google’s Android is a versatile operating system for mobile devices with support for more than a million apps. But there are some things Android doesn’t do out of the box right now, such as allowing you to make a complete backup of your disk image or blocking advertisements.

Both of those are things you can do on a device that’s been rooted, and there are dozens of other things that you can only do if you first root your device. But the availability of root access on Android devices is sort of a mixed bag.

On the one hand, it’s pretty cool to get complete control over your device. On the other hand, a rooted device is more vulnerable to some security threats than one that hasn’t been rooted — because apps can access portions of the operating system that are normally protected.

So Steve Kondik, the founder of the popular CyanogenMod custom version of Android, is starting to think about ways to minimize the need for root access.

CyanogenMod root

There are no plans to offer a version of CyanogenMod that doesn’t include root… at least not yet.

But if key apps and functions can run without root access, it would make Android a bit more secure.

As Android matures, Google has added a growing number of security features to the platform. As a side effect, this has made it tougher to gain full root access on Android 4.3 than earlier versions, but it also makes it tougher for malware to seriously mess up your phone or tablet or steal your data.

CyanogenMod already offers users the ability to choose how root access works. You can go into the development settings and decide whether root access should be disabled, enabled for apps, ADB, or both.

That will likely continue to be the case. But if developers can work with Android to enable root-like features without requiring root access, it’d be a lot easier for folks running custom ROMs to leave that “disabled” box checked.

Once upon a time, you couldn’t even easily take a screenshot on an Android phone without root access, but now the feature is built into the operating system. Maybe one day support for apps like Carbon and Titanium Backup will also be built in.

Support Liliputing

Liliputing's primary sources of revenue are advertising and affiliate links (if you click the "Shop" button at the top of the page and buy something on Amazon, for example, we'll get a small commission).

But there are several ways you can support the site directly even if you're using an ad blocker* and hate online shopping.

Contribute to our Patreon campaign

or...

Contribute via PayPal

* If you are using an ad blocker like uBlock Origin and seeing a pop-up message at the bottom of the screen, we have a guide that may help you disable it.

Subscribe to Liliputing via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 9,547 other subscribers

3 replies on “CyanogenMod contemplates Android without root”

  1. root is less needed as apps / OS progresses – i never bothered rooting my nexus 7 but in general any geek out there who wants a truly portable computer phone device has to have root. just got a lenovo s750 to replace a windows phone 8 deice and it came rooted, without root to manage the storage it wouldn’t be very usable. with root is great.

  2. Given that Cyanogenmod has already gone on record with holding back features following grumbling from Google and app developers, e.g. allowing the user to choose to provide a fake phone number or set of contacts to apps that require access to personal data, for privacy reasons (rather than letting them force close if you revoke their permissions to access personal data), you can bet that they’re not going to make ad blocking any easier than it already is. That’ll fall to other third-party ROMs based on CM. (For that matter, a few months back they even marked the “revoke app permissions” feature, which was present in early CM builds but not recently, as WONTFIX, and Google themselves has even included that functionality in a hidden menu in 4.3. Apparently they feel prohibiting apps from accessing your personal data is “security theater”.)

    But yay for adding more capabilities that don’t require root. There are some things that probably always will, like the touch emulation methods being used by the authors of analog joystick compatibility packages such as USB/BT Joystick Center, because it’s potentially disastrous to give one app the ability to send touch events to another without the user getting that root permissions dialog.

  3. I wonder if they can use sudo to avoid direct access to root. I don’t see any reason why root access couldn’t be restricted with it – but it would require app changes I’m sure.

Comments are closed.