A German court has issued a ruling in a patent case between Motorola and Apple which could lead to a temporary ban on sales of iPhones and iPads in Germany.
Motorola is charging the Apple’s mobile devices are infringing on a patent it holds related to GPRS wireless devices. But while the court ruling could lead to a preliminary injunction against Apple, things aren’t quite cut and dry.
Basically Motorola would have to put up a €100 million bond for the injunction to take effect… and if the ruling is later overturned on appeal, Motorola could lose that money.
In addition to fighting the ruling in court, Apple can try to license the technology for Motorola or redesigned the iPhone and iPad to get around the issue, although that could be rather difficult.
This is just the latest ruling in a long line of lawsuits between mobile device makers. This summer Thompson Reuters pout out a handy chart showing the latest lawsuits (at that time), and things just keep getting more and more complicated.
Apple has been aggressively going after companies that it says are infringing on its design and patent rights, with mixed success. The company has successfully won bans on some Samsung Galaxy Tab sales in Germany, but has failed to ban the same products in the US.
If this keeps up, soon you won’t be able to buy any tablets from any manufacturers in Germany.
We need global patent reform–kill software patents and make design patents very stringent, require the actual item to be the imaged item not some vague drawing. . . just to start with.
Nonetheless, it’s good to see apple take one on the chin but we all know apple takes whatever IP they want and uses it without paying for licenses–just as they did with Nokia. After all apple is the king thief of ideas/tech. . . good artist copy. . .
This is Awesome, and if I had the €100 million I would give it to Motorola just to see another byte taken out of that piece of Rotten Fruit. I bet that dead guy is screaming his head off and clawing at the top of his cardboard box…(but I fogot he has not been buried yet).
Amen, Apple needs to get a taste of it’s own medicine.
Comments are closed.