When you buy an eBook you might think you’re spending money on pretty much the same thing you’d get if you bought a paperback book: thousands of words composed by an author to tell a story, make an argument, or otherwise put ideas into words, paragraphs, and maybe even chapters.

Sure, an eBook isn’t a physical item that you can toss on a bookshelf, scribble on, or loan to a friend. But¬†you’d be mistaken for thinking it’s a good rather than a service.

A European Union Court would beg to differ.

kindle paperwhite

France and Luxembourg tax books at lower rates than other goods and both countries wanted to do the same for eBooks. But a EU court ruled that the reduced tax rates don’t apply to eBooks because they’re “electronically supplied services” rather than goods.

Authorities with the European Commission are leaving open the possibility that they could change their rules in the future so that eBooks could be taxed at the same reduced rates as printed books. But that doesn’t change the fact that a court just ruled that when you pay for a book what you’re paying for is a service rather than an item.

That probably shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone who’s been following news about digital books for a while. Essentially many¬†retailers that sell eBooks are actually selling a license agreement to read those books… which isn’t the same as selling the item itself, which is how Amazon was able to delete the worst book imaginable from the Kindles of customers who had purchased the book a few years ago.

The EU court’s ruling doesn’t really have anything to do with the license agreement though. Instead the court figures that since you can’t actually do anything with an eBook unless you have a device to read it on (such as a computer, tablet, or eReader), it’s a service rather than a good — and that only the device you read it on should be considered “tangible property.”

So unless you get an eReader with every book you buy, it’s not covered under the applicable law… at least for now.

via Reuters and WSJ

Support Liliputing

Liliputing's primary sources of revenue are advertising and affiliate links (if you click the "Shop" button at the top of the page and buy something on Amazon, for example, we'll get a small commission).

But there are several ways you can support the site directly even if you're using an ad blocker* and hate online shopping.

Contribute to our Patreon campaign

or...

Contribute via PayPal

* If you are using an ad blocker like uBlock Origin and seeing a pop-up message at the bottom of the screen, we have a guide that may help you disable it.

3 replies on “Are eBooks goods or services? An EU Court thinks they’re services”

  1. I wonder how the decision would have fallen if “eBooks are goods” had meant a higher tax rate? What I think is behind these things is falling revenues due to corporate success in evading taxation, so screw the little guy to refill the coffers.

  2. What happens if you decrypt the book and then print a hard copy ot
    it? The court ruling flies in the face of logic, considering that pretty
    much all books nowadays begin in electronic format, characters on an author’s
    computer word processor.

    Hopefully the EU will do away with DRM of ebooks, I don’t know how
    publishers have been able to get away with it thus far.

Comments are closed.