liliputing logo
  • Home
  • Products
  • Top stories
  • Reviews
  • Deals
  • Ultrabooks
  • Contact
  • About
 

VIA Nano clocks Intel Atom in kinda unfair test

  • Tweet
  • Email

atom-v-nano

The Intel Atom processor has become the defacto standard for netbooks in the developed world. Acer, Asus, Dell, HP, Lenovo, MSI, Toshiba, and other computer makers are all equipping mini-laptops with the low power CPU. But it’s not the only game in town. VIA’s Nano processor also uses less power than most traditional laptop processors, but provides better performance in many areas than the Intel Atom. 

Right now the VIA Nano CPU is only being used in a handful of Chinese devices and the Samsung NC20 12 inch laptop. 

But the folks at ZDNet UK decided to see how the Nano stacks up against the Atom. There’s just one problem: They compared the desktop version sof each processor, so it’s hard to say what kind of performance you’d get if you were using the chips in two similarly specced netbooks. For instance, the Nano chip used in the test has a 1.8GHz clock speed, while the Samsung NC20 tops out at 1.3GHz. 

That said, the article does make for an interesting read. In general, ZDNet found what you would expect: The Atom uses less power, and should therefore give you better battery life. But the Nano scored better on most tests measuring CPU and graphics performance. And neither chip is great for serious computing tasks like encrypting data or encoding media files.

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to our RSS feed, follow us on Twitter, or "like" us on Facebook. Thanks for visiting!

Posted on Wednesday, February 11th, 2009, 1:56 pm by Brad Linder




  • d

    i'm not sure a netbook is the best way to “encode media files”. long battery life instead of media encoding speed is more important in a netbook.

  • Linc (MonkeykIng)

    Wow, what a odd test. They tested the Atom 230? That isn't even the one CPU most people have in their netbooks. What is with these apples to aardvarks compassions? I’m sure VIA makes nice chip, but someone damn well better put it up against a Atom N270 if they want to tell me something.

    Wait and see…

    What I think needs to happen is for a VIA Nano machine to come out. And then a side by side ‘unit to unit’ test can be done. No some theoretical test rigs, just a real world test. In a real world test I’m sure a VIA Nano will do better. But can you see how maybe that not going to help them give the way tech is moving.

    I’d like to see how a netbook with a VIA Nano does in the real world stack up against a netbook with an Atom + Nvidia ION chip. See that is the crux of the issue. That is what VIA is really up against, so do they have a CPU GPU combination to match?
    .

  • Artthurko

    I have VIA Nano L2200@1.6GHz max. TPD 17W. It is LV processor for dextop Mini-ITX VIA VB8001-16.
    Performance betwen Intel Atom 230 /dextop/ and Intel Atom N270 is max. 5% +/-.
    Smasung NC20 have VIA Nano U2250 1.3+GHz processor, but with adaptive overcloking up to 1.6GHz !!! It is ULV processor ultra low voltage for ultra small notebooks (“netbooks”) max. TPD 8W -10W.

    Also VIA Nano L2200@1.6GHz (VIA VB8001-16) vs. Intel Atom N270 1.6GHz (Toshiba NB100) Win XP SP3:

    Performance Test 6.1
    CPU – Integer Math
    VIA Nano L2200@1.6GHz – 53.00
    Intel Atom N270 1.6GHz – 21.9

    CPU – Floating Point Math
    VIA Nano L2200@1.6GHz – 136.8
    Intel Atom N270 1.6GHz – 95.7

  • D

    Your statement about encrypting data is absolutely wrong the Via chip is phenomenal at encrypting data beating out even the Core 2 Duo

  • D

    Your statement about encrypting data is absolutely wrong the Via chip is phenomenal at encrypting data beating out even the Core 2 Duo

Facebook Twitter Gplus YouTube RSS

Recent Posts

  • Dell XPS 12 convertible Windows 8 tablet on the way?
  • MK802 $74 Android PC-on-a-stick shown off on video
  • HP loses part of its webOS team to Google

Featured Videos

  • Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (7.0) video review - Liliputing
    Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (7.0) video review - Liliputing
  • Kupa X11 tablet with Windows 8 Preview
    Kupa X11 tablet with Windows 8 Preview
  • CyanogenMod 9 nightlies for the HP TouchPad
    CyanogenMod 9 nightlies for the HP TouchPad


Popular Discussions

Powered by Disqus
mobiputing logo

Latest news from Mobiputing

  • Absinthe 2.0 untethered jailbreak for iOS 5.1.1 now available
  • Unofficially unlock AT&T HTC One X bootloader (with official tools)
  • Android apps can now use in-app billing for subscription content



2007-2012 Liliputing

Advertising | Privacy | TOP