MSI Wind vs. Eee PC 1000H: Battery life

Kevin Tofel of jkOnTheRun and I have been emailing back and forth over the last few days to coordinate a series of battery tests on the Asus Eee PC 1000H and MSI Wind with the 6 cell battery. Both computers have similar specs including a 10 inch display, 1.6GHz Intel Atom CPU, and 80GB hard drive. And both come with a 6 cell battery, although the Asus battery is 6600mAh while the Wind ships with a 5200mAh battery.

But it turns out that it’s difficult to make an apples to apples comparison because each notebook comes with its own power management features. The Asus Eee PC 1000H has a utility that lets you alternate between 1.2GHz, 1.6GHz, and 1.7GHz. At least I think that’s what it does. Unfortunately it displays the slightly less informative names “power saver,” ” high performance,” and “super high performance.”

The first time I ran my battery test using power saver mode, I got 265 minutes, but I later realized Windows XP was turning off the display after 10 or 15 minutes. I later ran the same test with no Windows XP power management features turned on and got 235 minutes. Kevin, on the other hand ran his first test with the MSI Wind running at full speed, so I tried one more test at high performance (1.6GHz) and got 199 minutes. Kevin decided to try another test using the awkwardly named “turbo” feature on his MSI Wind which underclocked his computer to 800MHz.

So how do the two computers stack up against one another in terms of battery life? On the closest we could arrange to an apples to apples test, the Eee PC 1000H laster for 3 hours and 19 minutes while running at 1.6GHz. The Wind got an extra 20 minutes and lasted for 3 hours and 39 minutes. It’s possible that the difference is due to subtle hardware differences between the two computers. Or it’s also possible that there was human error in the way we ran the tests. Either way, it’s not a huge difference, but the Wind definitely came out ahead here.

When running each computer using the manufacturer’s power saving mode, the Wind came out way ahead. At 800Mhz, Kevin’s Wind ran for 4 hours and 59 minutes, while my 1000H died after about 4 hours and 25 minutes when running at 1.2GHz. Of course, I suspect you’d get better performance on a machine running at 1.2GHz, but the difference might be marginal.

If all of these numbers seem low to you, keep in mind the fact that the Battery Eater test Kevin and I were running is designed to tax your CPU non-stop. If you spend most of your time surfing the web or writing documents, odds are youre CPU isn’t working as hard and you’ll get an extra hour or two out of the battery. Both Kevin and I estimate that we’ve been able to use our computers for 3 to 5 hours at a time without plugging them in, and I’d bet you could probably stretch that figure to 5 and a half or even 6 hours by dimming the screen a bit more and turning off WiFi if and when you’re not using it. Kevin says he thinks you might even be able to use a Wind for 7 hours if you can live with the performance hit that comes with running the computer at 800MHz.

  • http://liliputing.com/ Brad Linder

    Stay tuned for more info on this. Tropical Storm Hanna prevented Kevin and I
    from getting together this past weekend, but we plan to do a full comparison
    soon.

  • http://scottsoapbox.com Scott Kuban

    Nice battery life comparison… how do the keyboards compare?

  • http://www.stoett.com/ screen_doors

    Just trolling the web for more info on battery life – thanks for this info!

  • http://www.kis-systems.com rickb

    What about accessory features turned off/on? Like Bluetooth?

  • Sarah

    Interesting. I wonder what the maximum battery life of both of these machines would be when running in a power-saving but usable state – i.e. wifi/bluetooth off, CPU underclocked, screen always on but brightness set to low and no applications running (or maybe just a word processor).

    I remember in the late 90s everyone in our office had a Psion 5. Thanks to its comprehensive battery life reporting, there was an ongoing office competition to see who could get the most out of a pair of AA cells. I think 36 hours was the record. Now a netbook with a running time of 36 hours… that would really be something.

  • Pingback: MSI WIND en Español » Comparativa Batería Msi Wind y Asus Eee 1000H

  • Tonda

    Wind has slightly larger battery capacity (57.72Wh) while 1000H has 48.84Wh it could be expected that Wind will last longer.

  • Pingback: MSI-Wind SocketZone BLOG » Blog Archive » Test batterie: Wind U100 vs Eee PC 1000H

  • vietnameseloempia

    3 hours is bulsh*t. Even with the 6-cell battery of the wind i get 2 hours MAXIMUM!! The 3-cell version was even worse, 1:30 hours MAXIMUM. The machine is awesome, just the battery really bites!

  • vietnameseloempia

    3 hours is bulsh*t. Even with the 6-cell battery of the wind i get 2 hours MAXIMUM!! The 3-cell version was even worse, 1:30 hours MAXIMUM. The machine is awesome, just the battery really bites!

  • Eee

    The test that was done on the Eee Pc 1000H was with an earlier bios and without it's SuperHybrid Engine running.

    It was not until bios v.1005 (4TH BIOS release) or later did battery improvements started to show, also the previous BIOS did not have hyperthreading enabled on the CPU.

    With SuperHybrid running at the lowest power setting which clocks your cpu to 627 Mhz,
    I can run my Eee PC 1000H for about 5hs 20min with WIFI on brightness set at 25%.

    So thing have changed since this test.

  • Visenna

    Ok, but as far as i saw the 1000H is bigger then msi u100 (both with 6-cells battery). And the second thing is that 1000H uses GMA 900, what is older verson of GMA 945 which have u100. Am I right? Then even with quicker bios better is u100 because of better graphic….

  • http://liliputing.com Brad Linder

    They both have the same graphics processor.

  • Netbook Addict

    Has anyone bought a MSI wind with 320GB HDD? I got one yestreday but the trackpad is hot.

    Is it supposed to be like this?

  • Netbook Addict

    Has anyone bought a MSI wind with 320GB HDD? I got one yestreday but the trackpad is hot.

    Is it supposed to be like this?

  • http://www.laptopbatteriesinc.com.au/laptop-battery/asus/asus-eee-pc-1000h-battery Asus Eee PC 1000H Battery

    Asus Eee PC 1000H Battery 4 cell